1. ) ZAINUL AKMAL bin KASMANI 2. ) ROZLAN BIN AHMAD ZAINUDDIN 3. ) HAIMIYUSRY BIN SHUHAIMI 4. ) AHMAD ZAMRI BIN SHUHAIMI 5. ) FARIDAH BINTI HARUN 6. ) MARIA BINTI MUSA 7. ) MASHURI BIN BAKRI 8. ) WAKIL HARTA PESAKA RUSLINA BINTI ABD RAHIM v 1. ) WAKIL HARTA PESAKA SELAMAT BIN DAHLAN 2. ) Sahril Bin Kushairi 3. ) Pentadbir Tanah Daerah Klang PIHAK KETIGA MOHAMAD HAMIZAN BIN SELAMAT PIHAK KETIGA DICADANGKAN 1. ) khairul nizam bin mohd masnan 2. ) Anuar Bin Abd Ani 3. ) GEV INTERGRATED (M) SDN BHD
Catchwords
1. This case concerns a parcel of land which was initially transferred to one party, who subsequently subdivided and disposed of portions of the land to several sub-purchasers through informal arrangements. Thereafter, the same parcel of land became the subject of a separate and subsequent transfer to another entity. 2. Serious questions arise in relation to both sets of transactions. The circumstances surrounding the dealings disclose a number of irregularities which cast substantial doubt on their propriety and legitimacy. 3. The present proceedings therefore involve competing claims and counter-allegations among multiple parties. The Plaintiffs commenced this action against several Defendants, who in turn instituted third-party proceedings against a Third Party. The Third Party subsequently brought fourth-party proceedings against multiple Fourth Parties. 4. In these circumstances, this Court is required to carefully examine the sequence of events and transactions, assess the credibility and effect of the evidence adduced, and ultimately determine the parties’ respective rights, interests, and liabilities arising from the disputed dealings.
Judges (1)
Parties (15)
GEV INTERGRATED Sdn Bhd Proposed Third Party Pentadbir Tanah Daerah Klang Defendant Ahmad Zamri bin Shuhaimi Plaintiff Anuar bin Abd Ani Proposed Third Party Faridah binti Harun Plaintiff Haimiyusry bin Shuhaimi Plaintiff Khairul Nizam bin Mohd Masnan Proposed Third Party Maria binti Musa Plaintiff Mashuri bin Bakri Plaintiff Mohamad Hamizan bin Selamat Third Party Rozlan bin Ahmad Zainuddin Plaintiff Sahril bin Kushairi Defendant Wakil Harta Pesaka Ruslina binti Abd Rahim Plaintiff Wakil Harta Pesaka Selamat bin Dahlan Defendant Zainul Akmal bin Kasmani Plaintiff
Judgment
Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.
Read on eJudgmentSource: eJudgment (ba-22ncvc-36-01-2021)