ba-22ncvc-617-10-2017 — SCP Assets Sdn Bhd v 1. ) Ang Kim Jhew 2. ) Len Min Sin 3. ) Vinod Kumar Sharma 4. ) Mathew Thomas A/L Vargis Mathews 5. ) Tan Gay Beng 6. ) Tan Chin Tong 7. ) Ng Kok Chong 8. ) Edward Tan Tiong King 9. ) Iris Tan Kok Foong 10. ) Jordan Ang Jen Kim 11. ) PD2 Joint Management Body 12. ) Perbadanan Pengurusan PD II

Catchwords

Pusat Dagangan Phileo Damansara 2 is a commercial development-Management corporation passed resolution at 1st AGM to impose multiple rates of charges-Plaintiff’s car park parcels imposed highest rate of maintenance charges and sinking fund contribution objective to correct unequal allocation of share units when strata title issued-resolution challenged by Plaintiff-ultra vires Act 757-only single rate to be imposed unless it can be shown that the Plaintiff’s parcels are used for significantly different purposes under s.60(3)(b) of the SMA-all the parcels are commercial-no exclusivity in the common facilities-method of computation to arrive at the multiple rates challenged-the rates imposed are a collateral attack on the share units allocation-judicial review proceedings ought to have been instituted.

Judges (1)

Alice Loke Yee Ching Delivered

Counsel (8)

Chee Hoe & Associates Firm Ho, Loke & Koh Firm Angeline Ang Mei Fong Counsel Defendant Ashok Kandiah Counsel Plaintiff Celline Teh Counsel Plaintiff Lai Chee Hoe Counsel Defendant Ling Chee Wei Counsel Plaintiff Vignash Selvam Counsel Defendant

Parties (13)

Perbadanan Pengurusan PD II Defendant SCP ASSETS Sdn Bhd Plaintiff Ang Kim Jhew Defendant Edward Tan Tiong King Defendant Iris Tan Kok Foong Defendant Jordan Ang Jen Kim Defendant Len Min Sin Defendant Mathew Thomas a/l Vargis Mathews Defendant Ng Kok Chong Defendant Pd2 Joint Management Body Defendant Tan Chin Tong Defendant Tan Gay Beng Defendant Vinod Kumar Sharma Defendant

Statutes Cited

Rules of Court 2012

Strata Management Act 2013 (Cap 757)

Strata Titles Act 1985 (Cap 318)

Cases Cited (19)

MY (19)

[1974] 2 MLJ 214 [1986] 1 MLJ 490 [1991] 1 MLJ 428 [1993] 1 MLJ 393 [1994] 3 CLJ 567 [1994] 3 MLJ 185 [1995] 1 MLJ 308 [2002] MLJU 601 [2009] 6 CLJ 232 [2011] 2 MLJ 141 [2013] 6 MLJ 343 [2015] 6 MLJ 1 [2018] 2 MLJ 292 [2018] 4 MLJ 284 [2018] MLJU 1301 [2024] 1 MLJ 948 [2024] 6 MLJ 598 [2024] MLJU 168 [2025] 6 MLJ 283