MUHAMMAD NURHIDAYAT BIN ISMAIL v 1. ) MOHAMAD FIRDAUS BIN MOHD ZAIN 2. ) AINNA AIZAH BINTI SAYUN

ja-12b-58-09-2025 High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) 18 May 2026 • JA-12B-58-09/2025 • 24 min read
5 cases cited (0 SG, 5 foreign)

Catchwords

Rayuan – Kuantum gantirugi – Skop campur tangan Mahkamah Rayuan – Sama ada award berlebihan atau suatu anggaran yang jelas salah – Pang Ah Chee v Chong Kwee Sang – Prinsip double recovery – Pengasingan kecederaan – Mild head injury – Erectile dysfunction – Limitation of movement – Risiko osteoarthritis – Sama ada kecederaan berasingan boleh dinilai secara berasingan – Kos rawatan masa hadapan – Keperluan perubatan munasabah – Rawatan utama (PDE5i) vs rawatan alternatif (Caverjet, vacuum pump, penile prosthesis) – Sama ada tuntutan spekulatif – Gantirugi khas – Prinsip pembuktian ketat – Bil perubatan – Kos penjagaan – Ong Ah Long v Dr S Underwood – Kehilangan pendapatan sebenar (pre-trial) – Kaedah pengiraan berasaskan slip gaji – Sumarni v Yow Bing Kwong & Anor – Kehilangan pendapatan masa hadapan – Sama ada wujud kerugian sebenar – Loss of earning capacity – Risiko terhadap keupayaan masa hadapan – Award lump sum – Chong Chee Khong & Anor v Ng Yeow Hin – Causation – Hyperlipidemia – Sama ada berkait dengan kemalangan – Tuntutan tidak dibuktikan – Award diketepikan – Civil Law Act 1956 s 28A – Prinsip pampasan – Rayuan dibenarkan sebahagian.

Judges (1)

Manira binti Mohd Nor Delivered

Counsel (6)

Sekar Gill & C.Suran Firm Teo & Associates Firm Sekar Palaniandy Counsel Plaintiff Teo Han Lay Counsel Defendant Teo Woo En Counsel Defendant Thamayanthy Counsel Plaintiff

Parties (3)

Ainna Aizah binti Sayun Respondent Mohamad Firdaus bin Mohd Zain Respondent Muhammad Nurhidayat bin Ismail Appellant

Cases Cited (5)

MY (5)
[1983] 2 MLJ 324 [1985] 1 MLJ 153 [1985] 1 MLJ 30 [1997] 5 MLJ 786 [2008] 1 MLJ 608

Judgment

Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.

Read on eJudgment

Source: eJudgment (ja-12b-58-09-2025)