PERBADANAN PENGURUSAN RESIDENSI NOVO 8 v 1. ) KONG YENG SOON 2. ) MUHAMMAD SYAHMI BIN AYUB 3. ) TIAP-TIAP ORANG YANG BERADA DI DALAM PEJABAT PENGURUSAN PERBADANAN PENGURUSAN RESIDENSI NOVO 8
Catchwords
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Injunctions – Interlocutory mandatory injunction – Ex parte application – Application seeking delivery of possession of management office, corporate assets, electronic accounts and passwords – Whether interlocutory order would grant substance of final relief – Whether applicant established exceptionally strong and clear case – Whether court possessed high degree of assurance that similar relief would be granted at trial – Whether appropriate to grant mandatory injunction without notice – Rules of Court 2012 O 29 – Specific Relief Act 1950 ss 50, 51 & 53. CIVIL PROCEDURE: Injunctions – Ex parte injunction – Duty of full and frank disclosure – Disclosure of adverse matters including unstayed tribunal award, pending judicial review proceedings and related court proceedings – Whether duty of disclosure discharged – Effect of compliance with disclosure obligation on merits of application. CIVIL PROCEDURE: Injunctions – Balance of convenience – Adequacy of damages – Preservation of status quo – Rival claims to control of management corporation – Existing possession of management office by respondents – Whether balance of convenience favoured disturbance of existing state of affairs pending trial. LAND LAW: Strata management – Management corporation – Management committee – Rival management committees claiming authority to manage strata development – Validity of annual general meeting and election of committee members disputed – Effect of Strata Management Tribunal award declaring extraordinary general meeting invalid – Whether applicant established clear entitlement to possession and control of management corporation. LAND LAW: Strata management – Strata Management Tribunal – Award declaring extraordinary general meeting invalid and void – Judicial review proceedings pending – Leave granted but no stay obtained – Legal effect of unstayed award – Whether court should grant relief inconsistent with subsisting tribunal award pending disposal of judicial review. PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE: Ex parte proceedings – Mandatory interlocutory relief – Exceptional and extremely rare cases – Requirement of unusually strong and clear case – Whether existence of genuine and substantial dispute concerning lawful control of management corporation precluded grant of relief.
Judges (1)
Judgment
Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.
Read on eJudgmentSource: eJudgment (ma-24ncvc-173-06-2026)