KUALITI ALAM HIJAU (M) SDN BHD v 1. ) HHC INDUSTRIES SDN BHD 2. ) LIM SEOW BOON 3. ) LAI BAK HOON 4. ) UMMI HAZWAI BINTI AB HAMID 5. ) ANDREA NG PEI CHUN 6. ) SAIFUL AZWAN BIN YAHYA 7. ) TAN PENG HOOI 8. ) HHC GREEN GLOBAL MANUFACTURING SDN BHD

wa-22ncc-595-12-2020 High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) 18 August 2024 • WA-22NCC-595-12/2020 • 97 min read

23 cases cited (0 SG, 23 foreign)

Catchwords

EMPLOYMENT LAW: Employment relationship – Termination of employment – Whether employment effectively terminated on specified date – Continued EPF and SOCSO contributions – Whether continued statutory contributions prove ongoing full-time employment – Whether termination notices were validly issued – Whether subsequent work performed on freelance basis CONSPIRACY: Unlawful combination – Agreement to injure plaintiff – Whether defendants conspired to establish competing businesses – Whether coordinated mass resignation evidenced conspiracy – Whether circumstantial evidence sufficient to prove agreement BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY: Employee's duty of loyalty – Conflict of interest – Whether fiduciary duties ceased upon termination of employment – Whether establishment of competing businesses during employment constituted breach – Whether misuse of confidential information proven UNLAWFUL INTERFERENCE WITH TRADE: Intentional interference with business relationships – Whether termination of customer contracts done with plaintiff's authority – Whether diversion of customers constituted unlawful interference – Whether defendants acted with intention to injure plaintiff FRAUD AND FORGERY: Unauthorised use of digital signatures – Whether termination notices were forged documents – Whether defendants had authority to use company's digital signatures and stamps – Standard of proof for fraud allegations in civil proceedings CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES: Assessment of witness testimony – Material versus trivial discrepancies – Whether contemporaneous documents should be preferred over subsequent testimony – Adverse inference from non-production of documents

Judges (1)

Atan Mustaffa Yussof Ahmad Delivered

Counsel (6)

Ooi's Chambers Firm Viknesh & Yap Firm Edmund Chow Zi Sim Counsel Defendant Joanne Rachel Jankins Counsel Defendant Ooi She Yi Counsel Plaintiff S Viknesh Counsel Defendant

Parties (9)

HHC GREEN GLOBAL MANUFACTURING Sdn Bhd Defendant HHC INDUSTRIES Sdn Bhd Defendant KUALITI ALAM HIJAU Sdn Bhd Plaintiff Andrea Ng Pei Chun Defendant Lai Bak Hoon Defendant Lim Seow Boon Defendant Saiful Azwan bin Yahya Defendant Tan Peng Hooi Defendant Ummi Hazwai binti Ab Hamid Defendant

Statutes Cited

Employment Act 1955 (Cap 265)

Evidence Act 1950 (Cap 56)

Penal Code (Cap 574)

Cases Cited (23)

AU (1)

[2002] NSWSC 33

MY (22)

[1977] 1 MLJ 15 [1979] 2 MLJ 229 [2004] 1 CLJ 759 [2008] 5 MLJ 469 [2009] 3 MLJ 525 [2011] 8 MLJ 331 [2015] 4 CLJ 491 [2015] 5 MLJ 1 [2015] 6 CLJ 459 [2015] 6 MLRH 216 [2015] 8 CLJ 944 [2015] MLJU 2347 [2015] MLJU 33 [2016] 3 CLJ 676 [2016] 5 MLJ 91 [2016] MLJU 1203 [2017] MLJU 379 [2019] 2 CLJ 48 [2020] 7 CLJ 19 [2021] MLJU 166 [2022] MLJU 2814 [2024] 2 CLJ 43

Judgment

Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.

Read on eJudgment

Source: eJudgment (wa-22ncc-595-12-2020)