MY JET XPRESS AIRLINES SDN BHD v 1. ) MUHAMMAD ALLIF QAYYUM BIN MOHD DIN 2. ) AZRUL HISHAM BIN DATO ABDUL WAHAB 3. ) ZEN AVIATION SDN BHD 4. ) KHAW CHIN HUAT 5. ) INFINITY FREIGHT SERVICES & SOLUTION PTE LTD 6. ) QUAH LING MING 7. ) PATRICK CHEAH POH JIN PIHAK TERKILAN AIRMARK AVIATION (S) PTE LTD
4 cases cited
(0 SG, 4 foreign)
Catchwords
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Amendment of pleadings – Re-amendment of Amended Writ and Statement of Claim – Application to introduce new claims on eve of trial – Whether amendments allowable after 17-month delay following discovery under Anton Piller Order – Whether inordinate delay justified – Whether amendments properly particularized and bona fide – Whether prejudice to defendants could be compensated by costs PLEADINGS: Amendment – Late amendments – Whether amendments introducing new causes of action permissible – Whether amendments would change character of suit from conspiracy to contract claim – Whether amendments regarding fuel surcharges subject to arbitration agreement – Whether amendments would prejudice fair trial of action ARBITRATION: Stay of proceedings – Arbitration agreement – Whether claims sought to be introduced through amendments fall within scope of arbitration clause – Whether court should allow amendments that circumvent arbitration agreement – Whether arbitration objection can be raised at amendment stage
Judges (1)
Counsel (13)
Dason Raj & Partners Firm Harjit Sandhu, Wan & Associates Firm Nekoo Firm Dason Raj Counsel Defendant Harjit Singh Sandhu Counsel Plaintiff Ling Ying Xin Counsel Defendant Loh Ze Rong Counsel Defendant Nadia Amira Counsel Defendant Navinjit Singh Golen Counsel Plaintiff Pushpa Ratnam Counsel Defendant Ranusha Counsel Plaintiff Ras Harynni Counsel Plaintiff Ravi Neeko Counsel Defendant
Parties (9)
AIRMARK AVIATION PTE LTD Aggrieved Party INFINITY FREIGHT SERVICES & SOLUTION PTE LTD Defendant MY JET XPRESS AIRLINES Sdn Bhd Plaintiff ZEN AVIATION Sdn Bhd Defendant Azrul Hisham bin Dato Abdul Wahab Defendant Khaw Chin Huat Defendant Muhammad Allif Qayyum bin Mohd Din Defendant Patrick Cheah Poh Jin Defendant Quah Ling Ming Defendant
Statutes Cited
Rules of Court 2012
Cases Cited (4)
MY (4)
[1956] 1 MLJ 13 [2016] 1 MLJ 301 [2020] 3 MLJ 545 [2022] MLJU 1938
Judgment
Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.
Read on eJudgmentSource: eJudgment (wa-22ncc-93-02-2023)