1. ) DANNY FOO SEK HAN 2. ) MOHD RUSDI BIN DRAMAN @ YUSOF 3. ) MARDZIAH BINTI MOHAMAD 4. ) KEE E-LENE 5. ) NG SAI HOH @ NG SAY HOE 6. ) NG WEI LIN 7. ) TAN TAT CHIN @ TAN MAI 8. ) YEOH SHEAU IONG 9. ) YEOH TIONG TEE REALTY SDN BHD 10. ) CHRISTOPHER QUEK LI WEN 11. ) FOO WEI SZE 12. ) HO PHEA KEAT 13. ) HO YI WON 14. ) HO KEL WIN 15. ) HO JO EL 16. ) CHEONG HON WAI 17. ) LOH SOOK FERN 18. ) ENG BOON KEONG 19. ) LEONG SHET CHIN 20. ) LIM EIH GUARD 21. ) CHOW CHOI CHOI 22. ) YAP TOH MENG 23. ) M...
wa-22ncvc-183-03-2021 High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) 8 September 2025 • WA-22NCvC-183-03/2021 • 20 min read
Catchwords
The Plaintiffs seek declaratory and mandatory reliefs compelling completion of the strata title process and execution of Memorandum of Transfer (“MOT”), and general damages for loss of capital appreciation and diminution in value. The issues are: (a) Whether D1 breached its contractual obligations under the SPAs and whether declaratory/mandatory reliefs should issue; (b) Whether D2 bears contractual or statutory responsibility; (c) Whether Plaintiffs proved compensable loss (capital appreciation/diminution). - whether contractual and statutory obligations of D1 - Clauses 11(1) and (2) of the Schedule H SPAs executed between the Plaintiffs and D1 (co-executed by D2 as landowner. D2 not a “developer” within the meaning of section 5 HDA 1966 - expert valuation or market report not submitted. Court finds - D1 failed to discharge its continuing obligations under the SPA, particularly those prescribed in Clauses 11(1) and 11(2). - D2, the Datuk Bandar Kuala Lumpur, acted solely in its capacity as registered proprietor of the land and is not a licensed housing developer within the meaning of section 5 of the HDA Act 1966. There is no contractual, statutory, or factual basis upon which liability can be imposed against it.
Judges (1)
Counsel (9)
Parties (126)
KL ECO CITY Sdn Bhd Defendant PEDOMAN GIGIH Sdn Bhd Plaintiff REAL PARADISE Sdn Bhd Plaintiff YEOH TIONG TEE REALTY Sdn Bhd Plaintiff Andy Choong Kok Wooi Plaintiff Ang Yoke Kee Plaintiff Benjamin Ng Chong Jin Plaintiff Boey Sue Funn Plaintiff Bong Chai Lin Plaintiff Chai Soo Fung Plaintiff Chan Kwai Hoe Plaintiff Chan Pei Ling Plaintiff Chee Chiew Har Plaintiff Cheng Huiyuan Plaintiff Cheong Hon Wai Plaintiff Cheong Lai Yoong Plaintiff Chia Wing Too Plaintiff Chin Sin Yean Plaintiff Chong Foong Plaintiff Chong Hon Loong Plaintiff Chong Lai Foong Plaintiff Chong Wai Hoe Plaintiff Chong Wan Ling Plaintiff Chow Choi Choi Plaintiff Christopher Quek Li Wen Plaintiff Chung Siew Lan Plaintiff Cindy Tee Sin Yee Plaintiff Danny Foo Sek Han Plaintiff Darren Ng Heng Guan Plaintiff Datuk Bandar Kuala Lumpur Defendant Delia Chong Fui Min Plaintiff Devi Selvan Plaintiff Ee Fee C Plaintiff Elizabeth Victoria Cheung Plaintiff Eng Boon Keong Plaintiff Fiona Wong Yin Yee Plaintiff Foo Lan Foon Plaintiff Foo Wei Sze Plaintiff Goh Hock Chye Plaintiff Gregorius Ginting Plaintiff Hans Peter Fitch Plaintiff Heng Wee Kiat Plaintiff Hii Wang Soon Plaintiff Ho Jo El Plaintiff Ho Kel Win Plaintiff Ho Phea Keat Plaintiff Ho Yi Won Plaintiff Hor Kwai Meng Plaintiff How Chin Kwan Plaintiff Joann Melissa Chow Plaintiff Justin Lim Shao Cherm Plaintiff Kang Yew Jin Plaintiff Kee E-lene Plaintiff Khoo May Yong Plaintiff Koh Jon Young Plaintiff Kong Huey Fong Plaintiff Kong Kai Chen Plaintiff Kong Kai Huey Plaintiff Koo Bee Kheng Plaintiff Kua Boon Haun Plaintiff Lai Sooi Leong Plaintiff Law Chuan Shiun Plaintiff Lee Seak Sung @ Lee Seak Song Plaintiff Lee Yue Ming Plaintiff Leong Shet Chin Plaintiff Lim Eih Guard Plaintiff Lim Siew Yin Plaintiff Lim Swee Lian Plaintiff Loh Sook Fern Plaintiff Loke Ke Shin Plaintiff Loke Yoon Chee Plaintiff Low Han Jim Plaintiff Low Saw Cheng Plaintiff Mardziah binti Mohamad Plaintiff Mark Desmond Chow Plaintiff Mohd Rusdi bin Draman @ Yusof Plaintiff Ng Boon Kheong Plaintiff Ng Chau Fwu Plaintiff Ng Chen Ching Plaintiff Ng Sai Hoh @ Ng Say Hoe Plaintiff Ng Wei Lin Plaintiff Ng Woon Kiat (wu Wenjie) Plaintiff Ng Woon Song (wu Wensong) Plaintiff Ngiam Pick Ngoh Plaintiff Ngo Hea Bing Plaintiff Ong Chin Kooi Plaintiff Oon Pak Choo Plaintiff Pearly Goh Shumi Plaintiff Poon Kai Chong Plaintiff See Sing Yee Plaintiff Selvan a/l Govindasamy Plaintiff Seow Wai Cheng Plaintiff Sew Chaw Eng @ Siew Choon Eng Plaintiff Sia Siew Moon Plaintiff Soh Hei Sun Plaintiff Tan Ai Chin Plaintiff Tan Eng Bee Plaintiff Tan Hong Guan Plaintiff Tan Hong Leong Plaintiff Tan Poh Oon Plaintiff Tan Sok Hoon (chen Shuyun) Plaintiff Tan Tat Chin @ Tan Mai Plaintiff Tan Teck Leng Plaintiff Tee Ching Chew Plaintiff Tee Chuan Hong Plaintiff Teh Guat Sim Plaintiff Teh Wei Nee Plaintiff Teh Yu Xuan Plaintiff Teoh Han Boon Plaintiff Tiong Hock Chai Plaintiff Vincent Ye Eng Jian Plaintiff William Tan Chee Keong Plaintiff Wong Bee Bee Plaintiff Wong Ling Eiong Plaintiff Wong May Fung Plaintiff Wong Meng Way Plaintiff Wong Poh Lim Plaintiff Wong Siew Lin Plaintiff Wong Yee Siang Plaintiff Wong Yoke Lim Plaintiff Yap Keem Siah Plaintiff Yap Toh Meng Plaintiff Yap Wei Keing Plaintiff Yeoh Sheau Iong Plaintiff Yong Foi Lan Plaintiff Yong Loong Vun Plaintiff
Statutes Cited
Judgment
Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.
Read on eJudgmentSource: eJudgment (wa-22ncvc-183-03-2021)