Chin Chee Shung (Berniaga Atas Nama Dan Gaya Yan Seong Foundry [No. Perniagaan: Ip0101341-p]) v FELDA PALM INDUSTRIES SDN. BHD.
Catchwords
A dispute has arisen out of the Build, Own, Operate and Transfer (“BOOT”) Agreement dated 17.8.2015 (“BOOT Agreement”). Both parties were satisfied with the terms of this agreement after several discussions were held. In essence, the parties intended to cooperate into a business venture to process empty fruit brunch ("EFB") as a source of income for them. Nevertheless, what was supposed to be a fruitful business venture failed as a result of the defendant's alleged failure to comply with its obligations. In the ensuing disputes, the plaintiff seeks RM2,023,650.00 in agreed compensation, RM10,702,502.60 in lost profits, general damages, costs and interest. Meanwhile, the defendant filed a counterclaim seeking a declaration that the termination of the BOOT Agreement was unlawful, along with a claim for the rental of the plant and special damages. The defendant, however, abandoned their counterclaim during the trial. After reviewing all the evidence, the court finds that the BOOT Agreement had been validly terminated by the plaintiff. In this regard, the defendant failed to provide enough electricity to enable the plaintiff to fulfill his obligations under the BOOT Agreement. As a result, the plaintiff suffered losses. However, the plaintiff is only entitled to RM2,023,650.00 in agreed compensation, but not RM10,702,502.60 in lost profits.
Case Significance
Chin Chee Shung (Berniaga Atas Nama Dan Gaya Yan Seong Foundry [No. Perniagaa... is a High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) decision dated March 27, 2025 (citation: wa-22ncvc-41-01-2021). The case was decided by Raja Ahmad Mohzanuddin Shah bin Raja Mohzan.
What was the outcome of Chin Chee Shung (Berniaga Atas Nama Dan Gaya Yan Seong Foundry [No. Perniagaa...?
Chin Chee Shung (Berniaga Atas Nama Dan Gaya Yan Seong Foundry [No. Perniagaa... is a High Court decision dated March 27, 2025. The case was heard by Raja Ahmad Mohzanuddin Shah bin Raja Mohzan. See the full judgment for details.
Judgment
Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.
Read on eJudgmentSource: eJudgment (wa-22ncvc-41-01-2021)