1. ) MAEGALA A/P YEGAMBARAM 2. ) KOVILANCHANDRAN A/L SANNIASI 3. ) ONG HUOY YING 4. ) AMANDA STEFERNIE ONG CHING YING 5. ) JAYA KUMAR A/L SALLIAH 6. ) SALLIAH A/L GOVINDASAMY 7. ) Letchimy A/p Rathinam 8. ) S. Prema A/p Subramaniam 9. ) Kaitri A/p Kandiah 10. ) Suresh Kumar A/l Loganathan 11. ) Hareedharan A/l Tharumahputhiran 12. ) Bawany A/p Raja Gopal 13. ) NG MEI SHAN 14. ) LUM CHIN YEE 15. ) CHONG WAI YAN 16. ) Muhammad Taufiq Bin Yaakob 17. ) SARAVANA KUMAR A/L KARUPPAN 18. ) Wan Surian...

wa-24ncvc-1479-05-2022 High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) 12 January 2025 • WA-24NCvC-1479-05/2022

Catchwords

(a) Costs – Though at first instance, this Court was minded to order costs to be borne by the respective parties but it had allowed time for parties to consider the Obata-Ambak (supra) decision before proceeding with this hearing. Yet, the Purchasers continued to proceed, so costs for Suit 1479 in the sum of RM20,000 is awarded to the Developer (P3 is exempted). As it was heard together with Suit 2706, this Court will not impose costs on the Purchasers in Suit 2706. There is also no costs awarded against the Comptroller. Suit 1479 is dismissed except for the LAD claim for the 3rd Plaintiff/Purchaser and Suit 2706 is allowed.

Judges (1)

Roz Mawar binti Rozain Delivered

Parties (28)

TOTAL SOLID HOLDINGS Respondent TOTAL SOLID HOLDINGS Sdn Bhd Respondent Amanda Stefernie Ong Ching Ying Applicant Amiruddin bin Ibrahim Applicant Azri Sharif bin Badar Sharif Applicant Bawany a/p Raja Gopal Applicant Chong Wai Yan Applicant Hareedharan a/l Tharumahputhiran Applicant Jaya Kumar a/l Salliah Applicant Kaitri a/p Kandiah Applicant Kovilanchandran a/l Sanniasi Applicant Letchimy a/p Rathinam Applicant Lizafarizan binti Mohd Shaupi Applicant Lum Chin Yee Applicant Maegala a/p Yegambaram Applicant Muhamad Kairul Amri bin Abdullah Applicant Muhammad Taufiq bin Yaakob Applicant Ng Mei Shan Applicant Nur Aishah binti Ahmad Kamal Applicant Nur Atikah binti Kamaruzzaman Applicant Ong Huoy Ying Applicant S. Prema a/p Subramaniam Applicant Salliah a/l Govindasamy Applicant Saravana Kumar a/l Karuppan Applicant Siow Mei Kee Applicant Siti Noor Afeezah binti Ahmad Applicant Suresh Kumar a/l Loganathan Applicant Wan Suriani binti A Raman Applicant

Case Significance

1. ) MAEGALA A/P YEGAMBARAM 2. ) KOVILANCHANDRAN A/L SANNIASI 3. ) ONG HUOY Y... is a High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) decision dated January 12, 2025 (citation: wa-24ncvc-1479-05-2022). The case was decided by Roz Mawar binti Rozain.

What was the outcome of 1. ) MAEGALA A/P YEGAMBARAM 2. ) KOVILANCHANDRAN A/L SANNIASI 3. ) ONG HUOY Y...?

1. ) MAEGALA A/P YEGAMBARAM 2. ) KOVILANCHANDRAN A/L SANNIASI 3. ) ONG HUOY Y... is a High Court decision dated January 12, 2025. The case was heard by Roz Mawar binti Rozain. See the full judgment for details.

Judgment

Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.

Read on eJudgment

Source: eJudgment (wa-24ncvc-1479-05-2022)