1. ) HALIL IZRAN BIN ZAHID 2. ) NAIMAH BINTI MOHAMAD NOH 3. ) SITI NURUL AIN BINTI MOHD ZAWAWI 4. ) LOW PEI FENG 5. ) YULIZAH BINTI PARDI 6. ) FATIN NURAIN BINTI KAMARUZAMAN 7. ) HARYANTI BINTI IBRAHIM 8. ) MOHD SHAHRIL BIN MOHD SHAFI 9. ) MOHD SYAFIQ BIN MOHD SHAH 10. ) NUR HIDAYAH BINTI MARZUKHI 11. ) KAMARUZAMAN BIN AMAT 12. ) MUHAMMAD HAFIZ BIN ABDUL RAHMAN SITHIRAVEL 13. ) SITI NUR AISHAH BINTI SALIMON 14. ) AZNIZA BINTI MOHAMED 15. ) WAN HABIBULLAH BINTI WAN IBRAHIM 16. ) MOHD RIZAL BIN...
wa-24ncvc-5150-12-2024 High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) 7 December 2025 • WA-24NCvC-5150-12/2024 • 2 min read
Catchwords
Civil Procedure — Discovery — Pre-action discovery — Order 24, rule 7A, Rules of Court 2012 — Application for discovery after commencement of proceedings against developer — Whether application procedurally proper — Whether purpose of pre-action discovery to identify cause of action and proper party — Application dismissed Civil Procedure — Documents sought from non-party — Application for discovery against person not a party to proceedings — Whether discovery appropriate where proceedings already commenced — Order 24, rule 7A(7), Rules of Court 2012 — Prohibition on discovery after proceedings commenced Judicial Review — Challenge to extension of time granted by Ministry of Housing and Local Government — Whether application constitutes impermissible collateral challenge — Proper remedy is judicial review under Order 53 — Failure to file judicial review within prescribed time — Application dismissed Contract — Sale and Purchase Agreement — Delay in delivery of vacant possession — Claim for liquidated ascertained damages — Developer attributing delay to water supply system completion — Whether discovery against third party necessary to determine liability
Practice Areas
Judges (1)
Parties (28)
PENGURUSAN AIR SELANGOR Sdn Bhd Respondent Abdul Rasyid bin Kamaludin Applicant Azniza binti Mohamed Applicant Fatin Nurain binti Kamaruzaman Applicant Halil Izran bin Zahid Applicant Haryanti binti Ibrahim Applicant Jamaiah binti Sanusi Applicant Kamaruzaman bin Amat Applicant Lailatulistiqamah binti Karlin Applicant Low Pei Feng Applicant Mazni binti Mahmud Applicant Mohamad Efpyzul bin Murad Applicant Mohamad Nazar bin Saari Applicant Mohd Rizal bin Md Moktar Rudin Applicant Mohd Shahril bin Mohd Shafi Applicant Mohd Syafiq bin Mohd Shah Applicant Muhammad Farhan bin Faizal Applicant Muhammad Hafiz bin Abdul Rahman Sithiravel Applicant Naimah binti Mohamad Noh Applicant Noorhazimar binti Md Asli Applicant Nur Hidayah binti Marzukhi Applicant Nurhidayah binti Mohd Noor Applicant Siti Nor Hafizah binti Hashim Applicant Siti Nur Aishah binti Salimon Applicant Siti Nurul Ain binti Mohd Zawawi Applicant Siti Nuruljannah binti A.majid Applicant Wan Habibullah binti Wan Ibrahim Applicant Yulizah binti Pardi Applicant
Case Significance
1. ) HALIL IZRAN BIN ZAHID 2. ) NAIMAH BINTI MOHAMAD NOH 3. ) SITI NURUL AIN ... is a High Court (Mahkamah Tinggi) decision dated December 7, 2025 (citation: wa-24ncvc-5150-12-2024). The case was decided by Moh Kok Wai.
What was the outcome of 1. ) HALIL IZRAN BIN ZAHID 2. ) NAIMAH BINTI MOHAMAD NOH 3. ) SITI NURUL AIN ...?
1. ) HALIL IZRAN BIN ZAHID 2. ) NAIMAH BINTI MOHAMAD NOH 3. ) SITI NURUL AIN ... is a High Court decision dated December 7, 2025. The case was heard by Moh Kok Wai. See the full judgment for details.
Judgment
Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.
Read on eJudgmentSource: eJudgment (wa-24ncvc-5150-12-2024)