1. ) SODALITE SDN BHD 2. ) REKABARU SDN BHD 3. ) KINGTON TONG KUM LOONG v 1. ) IZEN KIARA 2 SUBSIDIARI MANAGEMENT CORPORATION 2. ) JADADISH CHANDRA A/L BIPIN CHANDRA 3. ) JAGJIT SINGH GILL 4. ) KHOO CHENG CHOOI 5. ) IAN OSWIN NORONHA 6. ) WONG SOO HAR @ JADE GOH PENCELAH 1. ) 1 MONT' KIARA DAN KIARA 2 MANAGEMENT CORPORATION 2. ) 1MK OFFICE SDN BHD PENCELAH DICADANGKAN 1MK RETAIL SDN BHD
Catchwords
ABSTRACT Plaintiffs sought accounting, refunds, and administrator appointment after a 2021 order nullified "Method B" maintenance charges at One Mont' Kiara. The Management Corporation held meetings passing resolutions for different rates across components based on exclusive facilities. Plaintiffs argued this violated the order and demanded uniform rates. Court dismissed the application: (1) became moot after 2025 compliance resolution; (2) s 60(3) SMA 2013 requires rate determination through general meetings; (3) different rates permitted under Aikbee Timbers for significantly different purposes; (4) relief sought exceeded original order's scope. KEYWORDS Maintenance charges; s 60(3) SMA 2013; significantly different purposes; Aikbee Timbers
Judges (1)
Parties (12)
1 MONT KIARA DAN KIARA 2 MANAGEMENT CORPORATION Intervener 1MK OFFICE Sdn Bhd Intervener 1MK RETAIL Sdn Bhd Proposed Intervener IZEN KIARA 2 SUBSIDIARI MANAGEMENT CORPORATION Respondent REKABARU Sdn Bhd Applicant SODALITE Sdn Bhd Applicant Ian Oswin Noronha Respondent Jadadish Chandra a/l Bipin Chandra Respondent Jagjit Singh Gill Respondent Khoo Cheng Chooi Respondent Kington Tong Kum Loong Applicant Wong Soo Har @ Jade Goh Respondent
Judgment
Read the full judgment on the official Malaysia Courts portal.
Read on eJudgmentSource: eJudgment (wa-24ncvc-729-04-2019)