Breach of statutory duty

3 cases · July 2021 to January 2026

Case Volume by Year

2

21

1

26

2021–2026

Key Issues & Sub-Topics

Whether the Defendants are liable for breach of statutory duty — Held, agree with the learned JC that the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th Defendants had breached both their common law duty of care and the statutory duty imposed on them whilst the deceased was in Tapah Prison. 2 a public authority acts in breach of statutory duty upon any failure to perform its mandatory statutory obligations. 1

Whether the Defendants are liable for breach of statutory duty — Held, agree with the learned JC that the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th Defendants had breached both their common law duty of care and the statutory duty imposed on them whilst the deceased was in Tapah Prison. 2 cases

a-01ncvcw-463-09-2019 RAHAYA BINTI SALLEH (PENTADBIR ESTET DAN TANGGUNGAN KAMARULNIZAM BIN ISMAIL, SIMATI) v 1. ) NIK MOHD GHAZALI B NIK ZUL AZHAR 2. ) EBBY SAIFUL BIN SULAIMAN 3. ) SARIHAN BIN HARUN 4. ) SASIBALEN A/L KARISIANAN 5. ) SJN SUHAIMI BIN ZAIDI 6. ) SJN AHMAD AZRUL BIN MOHD UJANG 7. ) Sjn Mohd Samsul Bin Saad 8. ) Abdullah Bin Haji Zaini 9. ) S/Insp Batumanathan a/l Murugesu 10. ) PKK Abdul Halim Bin Ma Hassan 11. ) ACP Rosli Bin Md Noor 12. ) Ketua Polis Negara 13. ) Kerajaan Malaysia

a-01ncvcw-71-02-2020 1. ) NIK MOHD GHAZALI B NIK ZUL AZHAR 2. ) EBBY SAIFUL BIN SULAIMAN 3. ) SARIHAN BIN HARUN 4. ) SASIBALEN A/L KARISIANAN 5. ) SJN SUHAIMI BIN ZAIDI 6. ) SJN AHMAD AZRUL BIN MOHD UJANG 7. ) Sjn Mohd Samsul Bin Saad 8. ) Abdullah Bin Haji Zaini 9. ) S/INSP Batumanathan a/l Murugesu 10. ) PKK Abdul Halim Bin Md Hassan 11. ) ACP Rosli Bin Md Noor 12. ) Ketua Polis Negara (Tan Sri Dato' Sri Khalid Bin Abu Bakar 13. ) Kerajaan Malaysia v RAHAYA BINTI SALLEH (PENTADBIR ESTET DAN TANGGUNGAN KAMARULNI...

a public authority acts in breach of statutory duty upon any failure to perform its mandatory statutory obligations. 1 case

bl-12bncvc-5-06-2024 1. ) Suseela A/p Retnam 2. ) S GANDHIMATHI A/P SUPPIAH v 1. ) Pentadbir Tanah Daerah Klang 2. ) PENGARAH TANAH DAN GALIAN SELANGOR

21 January 2026

Court Distribution

Key People & Firms

Top Judges

Yaacob bin Haji Md. Sam 2 Wira Hj Ahmad Nasfy bin Hj Yasin 2 Gunalan a/l Muniandy 2 Shamsulbahri bin Haji Ibrahim 1

Cases

bl-12bncvc-5-06-2024

1. ) Suseela A/p Retnam 2. ) S GANDHIMATHI A/P SUPPIAH v 1. ) Pentadbir Tanah Daerah Klang 2. ) PENGARAH TANAH DAN GALIAN SELANGOR

21 January 2026

a-01ncvcw-463-09-2019

RAHAYA BINTI SALLEH (PENTADBIR ESTET DAN TANGGUNGAN KAMARULNIZAM BIN ISMAIL, SIMATI) v 1. ) NIK MOHD GHAZALI B NIK ZUL AZHAR 2. ) EBBY SAIFUL BIN SULAIMAN 3. ) SARIHAN BIN HARUN 4. ) SASIBALEN A/L KARISIANAN 5. ) SJN SUHAIMI BIN ZAIDI 6. ) SJN AHMAD AZRUL BIN MOHD UJANG 7. ) Sjn Mohd Samsul Bin Saad 8. ) Abdullah Bin Haji Zaini 9. ) S/Insp Batumanathan a/l Murugesu 10. ) PKK Abdul Halim Bin Ma Hassan 11. ) ACP Rosli Bin Md Noor 12. ) Ketua Polis Negara 13. ) Kerajaan Malaysia

a-01ncvcw-71-02-2020

1. ) NIK MOHD GHAZALI B NIK ZUL AZHAR 2. ) EBBY SAIFUL BIN SULAIMAN 3. ) SARIHAN BIN HARUN 4. ) SASIBALEN A/L KARISIANAN 5. ) SJN SUHAIMI BIN ZAIDI 6. ) SJN AHMAD AZRUL BIN MOHD UJANG 7. ) Sjn Mohd Samsul Bin Saad 8. ) Abdullah Bin Haji Zaini 9. ) S/INSP Batumanathan a/l Murugesu 10. ) PKK Abdul Halim Bin Md Hassan 11. ) ACP Rosli Bin Md Noor 12. ) Ketua Polis Negara (Tan Sri Dato' Sri Khalid Bin Abu Bakar 13. ) Kerajaan Malaysia v RAHAYA BINTI SALLEH (PENTADBIR ESTET DAN TANGGUNGAN KAMARULNI...